W3SEQ
← All articles
LegalOctober 19, 2026 · 4 min

AI and copyright — what the law says

Creators who use generative AI (ChatGPT, Midjourney, Suno) — are their works protected by copyright? State of play in France and Europe.

By W3SEQ

Creators who use generative AI (ChatGPT, Midjourney, Suno) — are their works protected by copyright? State of play in France and Europe.

Since 2022, generative AI has transformed creative work. Music, images, texts, code — almost any output can now be produced with the help of AI. But this raises a legal question: can an AI-assisted work be protected by copyright?

The answer is nuanced. Here is the state of play.

The principle: originality requires a human

Under French law (article L.111-1 of the Intellectual Property Code) and European law, copyright protects original works — that is, works bearing the imprint of the author's personality.

The human contribution is a central criterion. A work produced entirely by an AI, without human intervention, is not protected by copyright in France.

Conversely, a work whose human contribution is substantial and identifiable is protected.

The question of human contribution

The debate focuses on the notion of human contribution. The French Supreme Court (Cour de cassation) and the European Court of Justice have not yet issued a definitive decision, but a consensus is emerging:

The human contribution must be:

  • Original — the author must have made free and creative choices
  • Substantial — the AI must not be the sole author of the work
  • Demonstrable — the author must be able to prove their contribution in case of dispute
The more the human intervenes (prompts, iterations, selections, edits), the more the human contribution is likely to be recognized.

What about prompts?

A prompt alone is generally not considered a work of authorship. It is an instruction, not a creation.

However, a very elaborate prompt (a long, structured, precise text that constitutes a genuine creative act) can, in some cases, be considered a work in its own right.

Case law will evolve on this point, but the current trend is cautious: the prompt is a tool, not a work.

The CSPLA recommendations

In 2024, the Conseil Supérieur de la Propriété Littéraire et Artistique (CSPLA) published a report on AI and copyright. The main recommendations:

  • Transparency: AI-generated content should be identifiable
  • Traceability: the human creative process should be documented
  • Compensation: authors whose works were used to train AI models should be compensated
  • Documentation: creators should keep a record of their creative process
This last recommendation is exactly what W3SEQ enables: documenting the human contribution through a creation journal.

How W3SEQ helps document human contribution

W3SEQ's sealed envelope contains several elements that let you document your human contribution:

  • The creation journal: a narrative description of the creative process (sources, prompts, iterations, final choices)
  • The prompt files: copies of the prompts used, if any
  • The SHA-256 hashes: proof that the files existed on a given date
  • The Ed25519 signature: cryptographic proof of authorship
In case of dispute, these elements let you demonstrate that the work bears your imprint, even if AI was involved.

Practical advice

If you create with AI, here are some best practices:

1. Keep a record of your creative process (prompts, iterations, choices) 2. Document your human contribution (what you decided, what you rejected, why) 3. Save intermediate versions (drafts, sketches, alternative takes) 4. Timestamp your works as soon as they're finished, before publishing 5. Mention AI use in your creation journal (transparency)

The bottom line

AI does not invalidate copyright — it complicates the demonstration of authorship.

Creators who use AI must be able to prove their human contribution. This requires documentation and rigor.

W3SEQ provides the technical means to do this. It does not replace legal advice — consult a lawyer for specific cases — but it provides a solid element of proof to support your copyright claims.

---

This article is informational only and does not constitute legal advice.